"I wanted to give this 3 1/2 stars, but I'll round up to four. I have two 3 month old kittens. Perhaps it is their size, perhaps it is the fact that I have spoiled them so rotten that they have dozens of toys to play with, but this isn't an immediate favorite.
They get super excited when this toy comes out because it rattles (huge plus) but they get kind of confused when I give it to them. I seems like it's too big for them. One of my kittens likes to carry toys in her mouth but this one is just too big. Pushed to four stars because of the rattle."